The antithesis original copy - authentic fake. A limitation in the valuation of non-European cultural goods? - This paper aims to be a tribute to Filippo Maria Gambari for the exchange of ideas in the period in which he directed the MuCiv, which has been enriched over time thanks to the dialogue with experts in the same Museum. This exchange of ideas took the form of an agreement, recently renewed. The agreement concerns, in particular, the post-graduate courses and the activities of the Laboratory on the False, DSU-Roma Tre, in which assets seized by the Carabinieri Command for the Protection of Cultural Heritage converge. The heterogeneity of these assets has highlighted various risk factors among which we want to underline, on this occasion, the one deriving from the cultural approach based on a single model. The recognition of an object as original or copy, authentic or false, is based on a judgment that is not universal and therefore requires particular attention. On the opposition between the words original/copy - authentic/false, which today define the very concept of «cultural property», as well as its absolute value for the owner and for the market, choices are based which can lead to the destruction of a object, rather than its protection. But if the reflection on the scope of these terms for the definition of material cultural assets produced in the EuroMediterranean area, in different eras, finds a firm point summarized by Cesare Brandi’s theory of restoration, how should we use the same words in relation to objects from non-European cultural backgrounds
Calcani, G. (2026). L'antitesi originale/copia - autentico - falso. Un limite nella valutazione di beni culturali extraeuropei?, in Boccuccia P., Baroni I. (a cura di), Connessioni. Oggetti, saperi, parole, culture e civiltà, Atti del Convegno Scientifico Internazionale dedicato a Filippo Maria Gambari (Roma Museo delle Civiltà 16-18 novembre 2022), Studi di Paletnologia 4, tomo I, Edizioni Espera 2026, pp. 51-58.. In I.B. P. Boccuccia (a cura di), Connessioni. Oggetti, saperi, parole, culture e civiltà, Atti del Convegno Scientifico Internazionale dedicato a Filippo Maria Gambari (Roma Museo delle Civiltà 16-18 novembre 2022), (pp. 51-58). Espera.
L'antitesi originale/copia - autentico - falso. Un limite nella valutazione di beni culturali extraeuropei?, in Boccuccia P., Baroni I. (a cura di), Connessioni. Oggetti, saperi, parole, culture e civiltà, Atti del Convegno Scientifico Internazionale dedicato a Filippo Maria Gambari (Roma Museo delle Civiltà 16-18 novembre 2022), Studi di Paletnologia 4, tomo I, Edizioni Espera 2026, pp. 51-58.
Giuliana Calcani
2026-01-01
Abstract
The antithesis original copy - authentic fake. A limitation in the valuation of non-European cultural goods? - This paper aims to be a tribute to Filippo Maria Gambari for the exchange of ideas in the period in which he directed the MuCiv, which has been enriched over time thanks to the dialogue with experts in the same Museum. This exchange of ideas took the form of an agreement, recently renewed. The agreement concerns, in particular, the post-graduate courses and the activities of the Laboratory on the False, DSU-Roma Tre, in which assets seized by the Carabinieri Command for the Protection of Cultural Heritage converge. The heterogeneity of these assets has highlighted various risk factors among which we want to underline, on this occasion, the one deriving from the cultural approach based on a single model. The recognition of an object as original or copy, authentic or false, is based on a judgment that is not universal and therefore requires particular attention. On the opposition between the words original/copy - authentic/false, which today define the very concept of «cultural property», as well as its absolute value for the owner and for the market, choices are based which can lead to the destruction of a object, rather than its protection. But if the reflection on the scope of these terms for the definition of material cultural assets produced in the EuroMediterranean area, in different eras, finds a firm point summarized by Cesare Brandi’s theory of restoration, how should we use the same words in relation to objects from non-European cultural backgroundsI documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.


