This article argues that the so-called “Greek popes” of the seventh and early eighth centuries played a decisive role in redefining papal authority through sophisticated strategies of visual, liturgical, and devotional communication. Rather than being marginal figures shaped by eastern migration, they actively exploited their cultural hybridity to renegotiate Rome’s relationship with Constantinople and to strengthen the political and doctrinal position of the Roman Church. The Monothelite controversy provided the principal context for this process, prompting the development of new forms of self-representation through images, relic cults, and monumental patronage. From Theodore I to Constantine I, artistic interventions at sites such as Santa Maria Antiqua, San Saba, and Old St Peter’s transformed theological arguments into compelling public narratives. The article demonstrates that these programmes did not simply reflect ecclesiastical policy but actively contributed to the construction of papal authority. By appropriating and reshaping Byzantine visual and ceremonial traditions, the Greek popes articulated a new vision of Roman primacy, laying the foundations for a stronger and more autonomous papacy within the early medieval Mediterranean world.
Bordi, G. (2026). «Once we were strangers». Papi greci e strategie di comunicazione tra Roma e Bisanzio. In R.S.V. Lucrezia Spera (a cura di), Roma e gli Altri (300-1000). Stranieri nella città tra conflitti e integrazione Atti del Convegno Internazionale PRIN 2022 (Roma, Università Roma Tre, Aula Magna, 11-12-13 dicembre 2025) (pp. 291-306). Mantova : SAP Società archeologica.
«Once we were strangers». Papi greci e strategie di comunicazione tra Roma e Bisanzio
Giulia Bordi
2026-01-01
Abstract
This article argues that the so-called “Greek popes” of the seventh and early eighth centuries played a decisive role in redefining papal authority through sophisticated strategies of visual, liturgical, and devotional communication. Rather than being marginal figures shaped by eastern migration, they actively exploited their cultural hybridity to renegotiate Rome’s relationship with Constantinople and to strengthen the political and doctrinal position of the Roman Church. The Monothelite controversy provided the principal context for this process, prompting the development of new forms of self-representation through images, relic cults, and monumental patronage. From Theodore I to Constantine I, artistic interventions at sites such as Santa Maria Antiqua, San Saba, and Old St Peter’s transformed theological arguments into compelling public narratives. The article demonstrates that these programmes did not simply reflect ecclesiastical policy but actively contributed to the construction of papal authority. By appropriating and reshaping Byzantine visual and ceremonial traditions, the Greek popes articulated a new vision of Roman primacy, laying the foundations for a stronger and more autonomous papacy within the early medieval Mediterranean world.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.


