The Politique de la Ville, grounded on an idea of equality that has not yet withdrawn despite economic downturns and political turnovers, was launched in the late 1970s, aiming at reducing territorial inequalities within disadvantaged neighbourhoods (Quartiers en crise) built after the Second World War. Ever since, several challenging generations of the “Politique de la Ville” have been set up addressing the specific domain of housing and urban environment and more general issues in employment, health, law and order, security and urban services. Their sphere of influence has gradually enlarged, interacting at the municipal level with by-law requirements to achieve 20% of social housing. In large urban areas, these issues are entrusted to the so-called Schémas de Cohérence territoriale (SCOTs), inter-municipal master-plans intended to manage sectoral policies related to real estate, public transportation and environment. Within the SCOTs, the challenge of inclusion is met both by a dilution of social housing estates located in the banlieues even through radical demolitions and reconstructions, and by infill practices of social dwellings in downtown areas. As for the governance model, the contract option (Contrat de Ville) issuing from private sector is increasingly shaping complex relationships among State, regions and municipalities as an aftermath of the administrative decentralization reform in the early 1980s: the local stage cuts across municipal elected officials and citizens, bringing about new routines based on reciprocal confidence. In this “tournant épistémologique”, the juxtaposition between advocates of comprehensive legitimacy (law and universal suffrage, but also technical knowledge and expertise), and supporters of a flexible right, or “negotiated law”, has been crucial. The action research processes led by individuals working with others in teams or as part of a “community of practice” have been from the very beginning strongly supported by enlightened civil servants, bureaucrats and “modernist” practitioners. Among the “Métiers de la Ville”, the “Chef de Projet” stands out as a mediator, facilitator and manager often coming from previous local militant experiences.

Palazzo, A.L. (2012). "Politique de la Ville" e "Projets de territoire". URBANISTICA, 149(gennaio-giugno), 4-7.

"Politique de la Ville" e "Projets de territoire"

PALAZZO, Anna Laura
2012-01-01

Abstract

The Politique de la Ville, grounded on an idea of equality that has not yet withdrawn despite economic downturns and political turnovers, was launched in the late 1970s, aiming at reducing territorial inequalities within disadvantaged neighbourhoods (Quartiers en crise) built after the Second World War. Ever since, several challenging generations of the “Politique de la Ville” have been set up addressing the specific domain of housing and urban environment and more general issues in employment, health, law and order, security and urban services. Their sphere of influence has gradually enlarged, interacting at the municipal level with by-law requirements to achieve 20% of social housing. In large urban areas, these issues are entrusted to the so-called Schémas de Cohérence territoriale (SCOTs), inter-municipal master-plans intended to manage sectoral policies related to real estate, public transportation and environment. Within the SCOTs, the challenge of inclusion is met both by a dilution of social housing estates located in the banlieues even through radical demolitions and reconstructions, and by infill practices of social dwellings in downtown areas. As for the governance model, the contract option (Contrat de Ville) issuing from private sector is increasingly shaping complex relationships among State, regions and municipalities as an aftermath of the administrative decentralization reform in the early 1980s: the local stage cuts across municipal elected officials and citizens, bringing about new routines based on reciprocal confidence. In this “tournant épistémologique”, the juxtaposition between advocates of comprehensive legitimacy (law and universal suffrage, but also technical knowledge and expertise), and supporters of a flexible right, or “negotiated law”, has been crucial. The action research processes led by individuals working with others in teams or as part of a “community of practice” have been from the very beginning strongly supported by enlightened civil servants, bureaucrats and “modernist” practitioners. Among the “Métiers de la Ville”, the “Chef de Projet” stands out as a mediator, facilitator and manager often coming from previous local militant experiences.
2012
La Politique de la Ville, improntata a una idea di uguaglianza che non ha sinora conosciuto arretramenti a dispetto delle congiunture economiche e degli avvicendamenti politico-amministrativi, è progressivamente migrata dai Grands Ensembles, per i quali era stata messa a punto, all’intero universo urbano promuovendo una mixité garantita da quote di edilizia sociale concordate a livello nazionale. Questa sfera allargata ha interferito, e talvolta produttivamente interagito, con le politiche ispirate dalla competizione urbana e con gli Schéma de Cohérence territoriale (SCOT), documenti di pianificazione strategica introdotti nel 2000 a livello di agglomerazione per governare i fenomeni di metropolizzazione. Nelle grandi aree urbane, lo SCOT è il dispositivo di coordinamento tra politiche di settore, come quelle relative al trasporto collettivo, all’ambiente e all’housing sociale: qui in particolare, anche in forza di un sostanziale obbligo alla cooperazione intercomunale, la sfida della integrazione e inclusione viene raccolta attraverso una diluizione dell’edilizia sociale nei territori di banlieue, anche con radicali demolizioni e ricostruzioni, e un suo infill in ambiti di rigenerazione particolarmente favoriti per presenza di risorse fondiarie e condizioni di accessibilità. Appare evidente che soltanto una “programmazione a monte” può farsi carico di tematizzare in maniera convincente competitività e coesione, affrontando per tempo il nodo delle compatibilità nelle aree di maggior sviluppo e predisponendo nei quartieri in crisi le condizioni per una transizione da un’economia “protetta” a un’economia di mercato . Sul piano della governance, la formula del contratto (il Contrat de Ville), di matrice privatistica, emerge a connotare relazioni interistituzionali (tra Stato, regioni, communautés e singoli comuni) sempre più complesse all’indomani degli energici provvedimenti di decentramento amministrativo degli anni Ottanta: il nuovo protagonismo municipale accorcia le distanze tra eletti, funzionari e cittadini, facendo emergere routines alimentate da nuovi rapporti di fiducia. In questo “tournant épistémologique” è risultato cruciale l’accostamento tra “depositari” delle forme riconosciute di legittimità razional-comprensiva (la legge e il suffragio universale, ma anche il sapere tecnico e l’expertise), con i nuovi attori della ricerca-azione, partigiani di un diritto flessibile, o “diritto negoziato”, entro cui si muovono gli istituti della Politique de la Ville, fortemente sostenuti dal riformismo illuminato di funzionari, burocrati e “giuristi modernisti”. E tra i “Métiers de la Ville”, si afferma la singolare figura di mediatore, facilitatore e manager dello “Chef de Projet”, proveniente spesso da forme di militanza locale.
Palazzo, A.L. (2012). "Politique de la Ville" e "Projets de territoire". URBANISTICA, 149(gennaio-giugno), 4-7.
File in questo prodotto:
Non ci sono file associati a questo prodotto.

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11590/138353
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact