Gravitational dynamics of an infinite shuffled lattice: Particle coarse-graining, nonlinear clustering, and the continuum limit

We study the evolution under their self-gravity of particles evolving from infinite "shuffled lattice" initial conditions. We focus here specifically on the comparison between the evolution of such a system and that of "daughter" coarse-grained particle distributions. These are sparser (i.e., lower density) particle distributions, defined by a simple coarse-graining procedure, which share the same large-scale mass fluctuations. We consider both the case that such coarse-grainings are performed (i) on the initial conditions, and (ii) at a finite time with a specific additional prescription. In numerical simulations we observe that, to a first approximation, these coarse-grainings represent well the evolution of the two-point correlation properties over a significant range of scales. We note, in particular, that the form of the two-point correlation function in the original system, when it is evolving in the asymptotic "self-similar" regime, may be reproduced well in a daughter coarse-grained system in which the dynamics are still dominated by two-body (nearest neighbor) interactions. This provides a simple physical description of the origin of the form of part of the asymptotic nonlinear correlation function. Using analytical results on the early time evolution of these systems, however, we show that small observed differences between the evolved system and its coarse-grainings at the initial time will in fact diverge as the ratio of the coarse-graining scale to the original interparticle distance increases. The second coarse-graining studied, performed at a finite time in a specified manner, circumvents this problem. It also makes it more physically transparent why gravitational dynamics from these initial conditions tends toward a self-similar evolution. We finally discuss the precise definition of a limit in which a continuum (specifically Vlasov-type) description of the observed linear and nonlinear evolution should be applicable. This requires the introduction of an additional intrinsic length scale (e.g., a physical smoothing in the force at small scales), which is kept fixed as the particle density diverges. In this limit the different coarse-grainings are equivalent and leave the evolution of the "mother" system invariant.