Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to introduce and formalize the Cultural Cyber-Critical Ecosystem (C3E) as a conceptual and operational framework for understanding Cultural Heritage as a cyber-critical domain. This study specifically addresses cyber-cognitive threats, identified as a pressing yet largely underexplored risk to the long-term preservation, integrity and intelligibility of Digital Cultural Assets (DCAs). Design/methodology/approach – This paper adopts a conceptual and analytical approach grounded in systems theory, resilience engineering and digital heritage studies. Core C3E concepts are mapped against emerging cyber-cognitive threat vectors using dependency analysis and the Functional Resonance Analysis Method (FRAM). Hybrid Infrastructures, such as DARIAH-IT, are examined as empirical reference cases to illustrate how human, cyber and physical layers interact across the full DCA life cycle. Findings – The analysis demonstrates that Cultural Heritage infrastructures exhibit critical dependencies not only at technical and organizational levels, but also at semantic, cognitive and trust levels. Cyber-cognitive dependencies – arising from human–AI interaction, distributed decision-making and semantic mediation – represent significant vulnerability channels capable of triggering cascading failures. At the same time, when properly governed, these dependencies enable resilience, adaptive capacity and long-term meaning preservation. The findings support the characterization of advanced heritage infrastructures as Hybrid Infrastructures with Critical Infrastructure properties. Originality/value – The paper provides the first conceptualization of Cultural Heritage as a Cultural Cyber-Critical Ecosystem. By explicitly integrating cyber-cognitive threats, dependency taxonomies and resilience modeling, it extends existing digital heritage and FAIR-based approaches toward a critical-infrastructure perspective. The C3E framework offers scholars, cultural operators and policymakers a novel lens for analyzing risk, trust, resilience and sustainability of digital cultural heritage. The novelty of C3E lies in four distinct contributions that collectively go beyond any single predecessor: (i) it reconceptualizes Digital Cultural Assets as cyber-cognitive targets – not merely technical objects to be preserved – introducing an adversarial dimension absent from digital preservation frameworks such as OAIS (ISO 14721) and FAIR; (ii) it applies Critical Infrastructure Protection (CIP) logic to the cultural domain by formalizing dependency taxonomies, cascading failure paths and resilience engineering principles (AMRL) that are structurally absent from heritage-specific frameworks; (iii) it grounds socio-technical systems theory in an explicitly mission-driven, governance-accountable model, operationalizing the human–cyber–physical layers through FRAM-based functional analysis rather than treating them as purely descriptive categories; and (iv) it introduces analytically novel constructs that have no direct equivalents in OAIS, FAIR or conventional CIP frameworks.

Bellini, E., Degl'Innocenti, E. (2026). Toward a cultural cyber-critical ecosystem: concepts, threats and challenges. DIGITAL LIBRARY PERSPECTIVES, 42(3), 581-606 [10.1108/dlp-01-2026-0031].

Toward a cultural cyber-critical ecosystem: concepts, threats and challenges

Bellini, Emanuele
Writing – Original Draft Preparation
;
2026-01-01

Abstract

Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to introduce and formalize the Cultural Cyber-Critical Ecosystem (C3E) as a conceptual and operational framework for understanding Cultural Heritage as a cyber-critical domain. This study specifically addresses cyber-cognitive threats, identified as a pressing yet largely underexplored risk to the long-term preservation, integrity and intelligibility of Digital Cultural Assets (DCAs). Design/methodology/approach – This paper adopts a conceptual and analytical approach grounded in systems theory, resilience engineering and digital heritage studies. Core C3E concepts are mapped against emerging cyber-cognitive threat vectors using dependency analysis and the Functional Resonance Analysis Method (FRAM). Hybrid Infrastructures, such as DARIAH-IT, are examined as empirical reference cases to illustrate how human, cyber and physical layers interact across the full DCA life cycle. Findings – The analysis demonstrates that Cultural Heritage infrastructures exhibit critical dependencies not only at technical and organizational levels, but also at semantic, cognitive and trust levels. Cyber-cognitive dependencies – arising from human–AI interaction, distributed decision-making and semantic mediation – represent significant vulnerability channels capable of triggering cascading failures. At the same time, when properly governed, these dependencies enable resilience, adaptive capacity and long-term meaning preservation. The findings support the characterization of advanced heritage infrastructures as Hybrid Infrastructures with Critical Infrastructure properties. Originality/value – The paper provides the first conceptualization of Cultural Heritage as a Cultural Cyber-Critical Ecosystem. By explicitly integrating cyber-cognitive threats, dependency taxonomies and resilience modeling, it extends existing digital heritage and FAIR-based approaches toward a critical-infrastructure perspective. The C3E framework offers scholars, cultural operators and policymakers a novel lens for analyzing risk, trust, resilience and sustainability of digital cultural heritage. The novelty of C3E lies in four distinct contributions that collectively go beyond any single predecessor: (i) it reconceptualizes Digital Cultural Assets as cyber-cognitive targets – not merely technical objects to be preserved – introducing an adversarial dimension absent from digital preservation frameworks such as OAIS (ISO 14721) and FAIR; (ii) it applies Critical Infrastructure Protection (CIP) logic to the cultural domain by formalizing dependency taxonomies, cascading failure paths and resilience engineering principles (AMRL) that are structurally absent from heritage-specific frameworks; (iii) it grounds socio-technical systems theory in an explicitly mission-driven, governance-accountable model, operationalizing the human–cyber–physical layers through FRAM-based functional analysis rather than treating them as purely descriptive categories; and (iv) it introduces analytically novel constructs that have no direct equivalents in OAIS, FAIR or conventional CIP frameworks.
2026
Bellini, E., Degl'Innocenti, E. (2026). Toward a cultural cyber-critical ecosystem: concepts, threats and challenges. DIGITAL LIBRARY PERSPECTIVES, 42(3), 581-606 [10.1108/dlp-01-2026-0031].
File in questo prodotto:
Non ci sono file associati a questo prodotto.

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11590/565317
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? 0
social impact